Susanne Boethius
Researcher
Män, våld och moralarbete : Rapporter från män som sökt behandling för våld i nära relationer
Men, violence and moral work : Reports from help-seeking men at treatment centrers working with violence in close relationships
Author
Summary, in English
Men, violence and moral work- Reports from help-seeking men at treatment centers working with violence in close relationships
Men’s violence against women is an extensive social problem. In the 1970s, a new kind of centers were
established in the US and UK, focusing on treating men who had been violent against their wives or girlfriends, the
aim which is to end the men’s violent behavior. In the 1980s the first center where violent men could seek help was
established in Sweden. Even though these treatment programs have been around for almost 30 years, they have
received limited attention from researchers and evaluators. Research in the field on domestic violence is less
frequently studied from the perspective of men rather than from the female perspective. This thesis explores how
men, who voluntarily sought help at men´s centers report their experiences of violence and treatment.
The study is based on two types of data; responses given on a questionnaire collected primarily for an evaluation
study, and analyses of qualitative interviews conducted for this thesis only. The results from the questionnaire shows
that, the men who seek help at a treatment center do not constitute a heterogeneous group. Some men report
frequent unilateral psychological, physical and sexual violence use against their partners. Other men report no
physical or sexual violence use at all. Many men report being exposed to their partner’s violence. The motives for
seeking help are not always to end the violent behavior. The possibility to assert whether the treatment was effective
is also discussed. There was no control group, meaning that there is no way to compare the results with those men
who did not participate in the treatment. However, the men report less violence use one year after the first contact
was made with the treatment center.
The main part of the analysis explores how the interviewed men present themselves. In other words, the thesis
highlights the men’s explanations and portrayals of their own retold experiences. The analysis shows that all the men
construct a morally decent description of their selves. Inspired by Scott & Lyman’s (1968) sociological concept
‘accounts’ and Goffman’s (1971) ‘presentation of self’, the moral work, made by presenting the retold violent acts and
their relationships, are identified.
Furthermore, the men switch between denying and claiming responsibility. At times they deny responsibility for
the violence used and place it with the women (“it’s her fault”), their background, or specific situations. At other
times they claim responsibility, and do this on three different levels; 1) in the situation, 2) by explaining that they
have been trying to end the relationship and 3) by arguing that they has been trying to seek help. The men also
negotiate the concepts of ‘violence’ and ‘women abuser’, making efforts to make distinctions between themselves
and “real” women abusers.
Men’s violence against women is an extensive social problem. In the 1970s, a new kind of centers were
established in the US and UK, focusing on treating men who had been violent against their wives or girlfriends, the
aim which is to end the men’s violent behavior. In the 1980s the first center where violent men could seek help was
established in Sweden. Even though these treatment programs have been around for almost 30 years, they have
received limited attention from researchers and evaluators. Research in the field on domestic violence is less
frequently studied from the perspective of men rather than from the female perspective. This thesis explores how
men, who voluntarily sought help at men´s centers report their experiences of violence and treatment.
The study is based on two types of data; responses given on a questionnaire collected primarily for an evaluation
study, and analyses of qualitative interviews conducted for this thesis only. The results from the questionnaire shows
that, the men who seek help at a treatment center do not constitute a heterogeneous group. Some men report
frequent unilateral psychological, physical and sexual violence use against their partners. Other men report no
physical or sexual violence use at all. Many men report being exposed to their partner’s violence. The motives for
seeking help are not always to end the violent behavior. The possibility to assert whether the treatment was effective
is also discussed. There was no control group, meaning that there is no way to compare the results with those men
who did not participate in the treatment. However, the men report less violence use one year after the first contact
was made with the treatment center.
The main part of the analysis explores how the interviewed men present themselves. In other words, the thesis
highlights the men’s explanations and portrayals of their own retold experiences. The analysis shows that all the men
construct a morally decent description of their selves. Inspired by Scott & Lyman’s (1968) sociological concept
‘accounts’ and Goffman’s (1971) ‘presentation of self’, the moral work, made by presenting the retold violent acts and
their relationships, are identified.
Furthermore, the men switch between denying and claiming responsibility. At times they deny responsibility for
the violence used and place it with the women (“it’s her fault”), their background, or specific situations. At other
times they claim responsibility, and do this on three different levels; 1) in the situation, 2) by explaining that they
have been trying to end the relationship and 3) by arguing that they has been trying to seek help. The men also
negotiate the concepts of ‘violence’ and ‘women abuser’, making efforts to make distinctions between themselves
and “real” women abusers.
Department/s
- Sociology
Publishing year
2015
Language
Swedish
Publication/Series
Lund Dissertations in Sociology
Volume
110
Full text
Document type
Dissertation
Publisher
Lund University
Topic
- Sociology
Keywords
- mäns våld mot kvinnor
- våld
- behandling av män
- moralarbete
- accounts
- våldsamma män
- Våld i nära relationer
Status
Published
Supervisor
- Malin Åkerström
ISBN/ISSN/Other
- ISSN: 1102-4712
- ISBN: 978-91-7623-451-8
- ISBN: 978-91-7623-450-1
Defence date
2 October 2015
Defence time
14:00
Defence place
Kulturens Auditorium, Tegnérsplatsen, Lund
Opponent
- Tove Pettersson (Docent)